If You Think A Recent Disaster Was A Judgment or Warning Sign...
Do you wonder if a recent natural disaster is an important prophetic sign? Are some calling it God’s judgment? Or that it fulfills a prophecy in the Bible? Are you feeling kind of nervous or worried after this disaster that it was a warning or wake-up call from God or telling us that the end is soon? If so, then learn why natural disasters are not prophetic and not warning signs of the need to act...except for one thing that applies always.By Tim McHyde
While being a Bible-reading believer is supposed to bring you peace, wisdom and maybe even some insight into the future via Bible prophecy, in practice it tends to have the opposite effect. The reason is found in the saying that “a little knowledge is dangerous.” When you know that Jesus spoke about certain prophetic events being “the beginning of sorrows” or “birth pains” of the end, but you have a vague understanding of what those events are, you tend to match them vaguely with similar disasters in current events—just to be safe and not “miss what God might be trying to tell us.” Sound familiar?
Supernatural Natural Disasters?
For example, when natural disasters happen, Christian speculation flies about them being supernatural disasters or directed by God for some reason such as a warning sign. A popular theory about many natural disasters is that they are judgment for some recent heinous act of Congress, the president or the people. If a hurricane happens to disrupt something sinful like a gay pride festival, many Christians will say it was no accident where the hurricane's path took it. (Where are these people to explain when a hurricane disrupts many good things as is more often the case?)
2012's Hurricane Sandy is no exception. Christians attached all kinds of significance to it. The satellite image below of Hurricane Sandy with the caption “Provoking the Almighty” was shared around on Facebook at the time.
Of course, this is just one opinion on the storm with no proof to back it up. As such, many Christians would disagree with it and feel comfortable doing so.
“God Told Me...”
However, disagreeing gets awkward when your Christian brothers bring out their personal revelations from God about that latest natural disaster. Consider this “word” about Hurricane Sandy:
It has been drawn to my attention that the path of Hurricane Sandy made the shape of the Hebrew Letter LAMED, ל. I find that most interesting as this letter in Hebrew means to learn, it also speaks of the King of Kings. This very strongly indicates to me that the King of Kings is not only telling us something but He is teaching us how He feels about what is happening in the United States of America.
When I first noticed the path of the storm Sandy looked like Lamed, I stopped and begin to pray over this, and during prayer and asking God what did this mean, I heard in my spirit that small still voice that speaks to those who know His Voice.
"This is the beginning of Great Sorrows for the Churches have fornicated with other gods and have offered up prayers that are a stench to my nostrils. Those who have called themselves people of God have deceived the people and fed their own bellies with unclean foods of greed and spiritual pride. No man can save them now, for those who know me and I them must know My Word is the Beginning and the End of all things, now it must rain on the just and the unjust alike. There is still time for repentance for those who have sinned against Me, but Judgment now will fall on the Nations who have come against Jerusalem and My people.
As for Jerusalem I say to you, I will cleanse my house first, fall on your faces and repent before it is too late. You have invited horrible sins into My House and the time for cleansing has come near."
Now how comfortable would you be disagreeing (when it means a word from a brother is false)? This person is convinced that God directed the hurricane's path into a certain shape to tell us something about the USA. He believes he heard from God that he is displeased with the churches and that judgment is now coming on the world. Do we dare suggest that maybe he is mistaken about the source of the “word” he attributes to God? Can you already hear a “despise not prophesyings” (1Th 5:2) coming our way?
Why Natural Disaster X Is Not From God
I will take one for the team here and argue that, with all due respect, maybe such words are mistaken and that natural disasters are just natural disasters unless something missing is present.
There are two reasons I feel this is most likely the safest conclusion.
1. God Does Not Send Ambiguous, Unclear Signs
The major problem with the idea that these natural disasters are signs from God is just that, they are normal natural disasters. While there have been several books written on how weather has been a sign from God, these events have been occurring throughout our history and have become a normal part of our lives. There is nothing unique or unprecedented about them.
Further, science has given us quite adequate explanations for why storms, earthquakes or tsunamis happen. Therefore, when they happen, they have no more special meaning than a rainy day does. We know what causes the rain and we do not think God caused it to rain. (Perhaps if the rain causes flooding or other disasters, then some might begin to wonder if God is mad at us and caused it, just as with hurricanes.)
Now, God can do anything including send a flood or a storm. The Bible records that he has done just that. He sent the great flood in Noah's time as a judgment on the world. He has even sent rain as a sign. But how do you know when God is doing it and when it is natural? It's easier than you think. The Bible shows at least two distinct ways God does this.
A. Signs + Prophet's Explanation
In many of the stories of judgment in the Bible, the pattern is that God will send a prophet to warn a nation, then to predict what will happen and to explain why it will happen or has happened leaving no ambiguity or guessing required. In the time of the prophet Samuel, God sent rain as a sign. He did this in connection with the people rejecting him and asking for a king (a request later met by the first king, Saul). Let's review how people knew that this was no ordinary rain and what its meaning was:
1 Samuel 12:16-20 (KJV) — 16 Now therefore stand and see this great thing, which the LORD will do before your eyes. 17 Is it not wheat harvest to day? I will call unto the LORD, and he shall send thunder and rain; that ye may perceive and see that your wickedness is great, which ye have done in the sight of the LORD, in asking you a king. 18 So Samuel called unto the LORD; and the LORD sent thunder and rain that day: and all the people greatly feared the LORD and Samuel.
The wheat harvest came in the dry season. It was therefore highly unusual and noteworthy for it to rain then. It was a sign. More importantly, no doubt was left as to its meaning for the people as the prophet Samuel both predicted it would happen and expounded the reason for it and what it meant:
- God had indeed sent the unusual harvest rain. It was not just a fluke of nature.
- God did this because he was displeased with their request for a human king to lead them, taking his place. He was warning them about their disobedience.
B. Standalone Signs - Painfully Clear
When a nation does not have an established, recognized prophet like Israel did, how does God express his will to that nation? Naturally, this question is of great interest to us today because it matches our very own "non-prophet" situation. Some believe that in this situation God can use ambiguous signs that are subjectively judged using the Bible to fill in for a prophet to identify, interpret or explain the signs.
Curse Those Who Curse Israel? (With Storms)
For example, you may have heard the theory that natural disasters befall America when she goes against Israel (such as by making her give up land, stop her settlements or otherwise). This supposed phenomenom is caused by God's promise to Abraham to bless those who bless him and curse those who curse him (Gen 12:3). Based on this (and a tenuous equating of modern wicked Israel with righteous Abraham who the promise was spoken to), when America "does evil" against Israel, a curse is returned in the form of a storm or other natural disaster--because of this special protection for Abraham--and apparently his descendants (err, minus the Ishmaelites/Arabs!).
But if this is so, then how is everyone but a select few missing it? Reasonable people rightly argue that there is no clear, consistent curse-Israel-receive-diaster corrolation and that those who say there is are suffering from a "confirmation bias" or ignoring evidence that contradicts their theory. Skeptics can also point to how God has worked in a more consistent manner in the past with curses on nations when he wants them to do something.
The Book of Samuel has a great example of how God works in prophet-less situations to once again make it crystal clear and unambiguous when he is doing something or when action is required on the part of a people. After the Philistines captured the ark from Israel (1Sa 5:1), unusual and drastic events began to happen wherever the ark was:
- Where they first put the ark in the temple of Dagon in Ashdod, the next morning they found Dagon fallen down bowing in front of the ark (1Sa 5:2-3).
- The next day they found the same thing but with the head and hands broken off (1Sa 5:4).
- Severe plagues of tumors, rats or even bubonic plague (uncertain) began in Ashdod. It became so heavy with so many tumors and deaths that they moved the ark to Gath (1Sa 5:6-8, 12).
- The plagues stopped in Ashdod but began in Gath (1Sa 5:9).
- This pattern repeated for a total of five cities (Ashdod, Gath, Ashkelon, Gaza and Ekron) over seven months (1Sa 6:17, 2).
At that point what do you think the Philistines were thinking? As uneducated as these peoples were compared to us, they properly put two and two together to conclude that the "ark of Israel's God" was the source of the recent plagues and that God wanted them to send it back (1Sa 5:11). The method they choose to do so was clever in that it also provided further confirmation that everything that had transpired over the past seven months was indeed God's hand against them and not just coincidence (1Sa 6:9-12).
If God is using or sending storms or disasters on America (where we have no established national prophet) to communicate his will on treatment of Israel or anything else, we can expect it to follow a similar pattern. Anything less than a painfully clear and easily corraborable pattern is not going to be effective for God to get his point across. It is proper for us to doubt theories that depend on us subjectively judging something from God or to ignore good evidence to the contrary.
2. God Does Not Expect Us To Take Just Anyone's “Word”
Which brings us to the next point about the claimed prophetic words from Christians explaining these disasters as God's doing, after the fact. If a person came who established a track record of successful accurate predictions in God's name before the disaster event, they would establish themselves as someone God is speaking through. Their reputation would proceed them and their fame would grow and spread.
This is exactly what happened with the prophets of the Bible. People knew there was a “prophet in Israel” even in neighboring nations because of their acts (2Ki 5:2-3, 8; 6:12). Therefore, if someone claimed to have a word from God but was not known to be a prophet, it was foolish to listen to them and your blood was on your own head. This was literally true in the story of the man of God who obeyed the deception of old prophet he did not know and was judged by God for it (1Ki 13:11-34). Samuel became known in all Israel after a flawless track record of his words:
1 Samuel 3:19-20 (HCSB) — 19 Samuel grew, and the LORD was with him, and He fulfilled everything Samuel prophesied. 20 All Israel from Dan to Beer-sheba knew that Samuel was a confirmed prophet of the LORD.
Prophets, especially new ones, also cemented their status through signs. When Moses was sent by God to lead the Israelites out of Egypt, he did not send him empty-handed. It is important to remember that he gave him three certifying signs: 1. the staff that turned into a snake; 2. the ability to make his hand turn leprous and healthy again by sticking it in his vest; and 3. the ability to turn the Nile waters to blood (Ex 4:1-9). God did not expect the Israelites to listen to just anyone who arrived out of the desert claiming he had come to liberate them without proof!
My point is, when it comes to our Christian brothers who claim to have a word from God, you are under no obligation to believe them if they have no track record. In fact, you are showing discernment if you question the validity of their prophetic words.
Testing Prophetic Words
If someone manages to pass the above test there is yet another one we should know and use. This one is important because it will allow you to not be deceived by the Beast and False Prophet in the end times who like God's prophets will be able to do supernatural signs.
The Bible establishes the principle that not every word should be accepted as true just because a brother or self-proclaimed prophet says it, but they need to be evaluated:
Isaiah 8:20 (KJV) — To the law and to the testimony [revelation from God given to Israel]: if they speak not according to this word, it is because there is no light in them.
This somewhat cryptic verse is made plain by the New American Commentary – Volume 15a: Isaiah 1-39:
God's past revelation is the only valid guide to judge any new wisdom about the future. Anything that contradicts what God has said or leads one in a direction inconsistent with the clear teachings in the nation's traditions is untrustworthy and misleading. The light of God's truth is not in it.
Without a doubt, it is a challenge to apply this test. The Bible is often unclear and open to interpretation, so who is to say for sure if a word agrees with the Bible or is contradicted by it? It takes practice and then some more practice. Yet your discernment does grow and soon you will be able to rule out some words, especially about end time events, by comparing it to the Bible.
However, do not worry about needing to be a Bible expert to not be deceived by words. These days, the first test will filter out 100% of the anonymous, unreliable sources of words out there. Just as the False Prophet is still not here working powerful signs, neither is there a prophet of God doing signs and multiple accurate predictions like the prophets of the Bible did.
If a prophetic word still nags at you after considering all this, you can always do what Gideon did and ask for a confirming sign as in the story of Gideon's fleece (Jdg 6:37-40). Note that God was not angry at Gideon for doing so! Again, God wants us to be safe and secure in following only him. If we have a doubt about a supposed word of God and we pray and ask for confirmation or a sign but none is given, it is safe and proper to judge that word as not from God and ignore it.
Conclusion – Yes, God Speaks to Us Today, But...
In case any of the above gives someone the wrong idea, let me conclude with the clarification that:
- I'm not saying God cannot spawn or use natural disasters to render judgment or get our attention today. Rather, my point is that the pattern of the Bible is for God to announce this disaster specifically beforehand through a prophet who explains the meaning clearly.
- I'm also not denying that God gives prophetic words about disasters (or other things) to his servants today. Prophecy still is given and received today. However, words today seem to always come from anonymous or unknown strangers over the Internet with no known history of accuracy and always after the event has happened. Even famous Christian “prophets” do not have a solid track record to back them up, let alone accompanying signs which biblical prophets used. The teaching of the Bible is to not follow or fear what these people say (Dt 18:20-22).
There will always be Christians ready to label the latest natural disaster as a warning, sign or judgment from God. They may even have prophetic words to back them up. If you evaluate them against the biblical patterns shared above, you should find these theories and words much less worrisome than they were at first.
Save your worry for when God sends a real prophet working signs and wonders and making accurate specific predictions successfully. God promises to do just that in the time coming up just before the Day of the Lord (Mal 4:5). When he appears, the events of the Book of Revelation will not be far behind.
But until then, do not fear that you may be missing God's mysterious warnings or other messages through natural disasters. We already have the warning in the Bible that the end is coming and that we need to be ready by doing the one thing that God has required of his servants of all time. We are to practice being truly set apart people (different from the world around us) who act in love towards God and neighbor like Jesus did. If you wish, let the urgency and anxiety that comes from disasters serve as a reminder of our need for God's protection every day and to be focusing on him to receive that. If we do this, we will already be God's faithful servants in the end times who he leads to protection from the global disasters that come.
If you liked this article, you will LOVE my book, Know the Future, a comprehensive, literal explanation of end time prophecy read by over 21,000 people since 2005.
It explains more on prophecy than all this site's articles combined and is up-to-date in its 8th edition, in both softcover and ebook. Note: By buying my book you not only bless us both (yourself with understanding and me with support), but you also bless others with the new articles you enable me to write.
Tim McHyde is the founder of EscapeAllTheseThings .com and a blogger on Bible prophecy since 1999. To read more from Tim and not miss a single new article, please sign up for his free newsletter below.
Email this article to a friend
Feedback / Questions (e.g., "Tim, what does Bible prophecy mean by...").
Articles on If You Think A Recent Disaster Was A Judgment or Warning Sign...
Don't Be Confused About Bible Prophecy Another MinuteHere's the Bible Prophecy breakthrough you've been waiting for—from two overlooked keys in the hard sayings of Jesus now made plain in the most accurate prophecy research available, because it departs from traditional "anything goes" allegorical interpretations which disregard Jesus' only statement on how to interpret Scripture correctly. (Learn these keys of Jesus in this free article...)
A Reader Comments:
“I've been searching all of my adult life for this kind of wisdom! I have listened to Irvin Baxter for 13 years and the Prophecy Club off and on for the same amount of time. I felt like I only had bits and pieces of the big picture. Then I hit the "wisdom and understanding jackpot" the next night when I typed "Prophecy" into a google search and out of all the sights that were available, I clicked on Tim's site first! It was like God pulled a needle out of a haystack for me in answer to my prayer from the day before!”